Nonprofit Harvest

Assisting nonprofits gather financial management resources that will help them build sustainable futures.

November 23, 2009

What I’m Thankful For – Strategic Collaboration

Filed under: Collaboration, Economy, Minnesota, Miscellaneous, News, Philanthropy, Social Media — Tags: , , — ashley @ 3:00 pm

Tomorrow I’m going home for Thanksgiving, and I’m looking forward to seeing friends and family for the first time in a while.  I live half a country away, so I don’t get home as often as I would like.

I think it’s interesting, and timely, that in the last few weeks both my original and adopted hometowns blew me away by their community and collaborative spirit.

Partnerships That Produce Results

First, Buffalo, NY took full advantage of Extreme Makeover: Home Edition coming to town, using the opportunity to transform an entire neighborhood and illustrate the importance of green building practices, such as deconstruction.

Then Minnesotans donated more than $14 million dollars to 3,141 nonprofit organizations in 24 hours, setting a national record. That is certainly above average.

Wow.

Neither effort would have been possible without significant community support – in the form of 5,000 volunteers and 38,778 donors, respectively – as well as the work of countless organizations behind the the scenes and some public-private partnerships.

There is no reaction except to be humbled. But there are lessons that we can learn for projects large and small.

Let’s Collaborate

Right now, everyone who wants to improve the nonprofit sector is emphasizing collaboration.  Certainly in some instances the results are impressive.  But successful partnerships take a lot of work and trust.

There is no one size fits all model. Collaborations range from joining forces on a project to combining backroom operations to a full merger.  Advantages include increasing impact or taking advantage of unique skill sets, such as in these examples, and minimizing costs.  Challenges include letting go of control, managing the needs of diverse stakeholders, and confusion around roles and responsibilities.

GiveMN as an Example

The GiveMN Give to the Max Day effort was incredibly successful in promoting individual giving, engaging new donors, increasing online donations, and getting significant amounts of cash into the hands of nonprofit organizations.

However, there was also confusion around some details, especially the matching funds. Regardless of how the uncertainty happened, it underscores the importance of clear communications among stakeholders – in this case that includes the 3,141 nonprofits, 38,778 donors, and the project partners.  Everyone needs to be on the same page about project goals and outcomes.

Beyond illustrating the widespread community support for Minnesota’s nonprofit sector, GiveMN also shows that nonprofits and their supporters can effectively use social media and other online tools to leverage their networks to take action.  There was an earned media blitz from the partners, but organizations and individuals took advantage of email, facebook, and twitter to get the word out.  The very nature of social media is collaborative.

What are your stories of collaboration? What lessons have you learned from those experiences?

Case Studies

Tools and Resources

Scenario Planning

The McKinsey Quarterly recently wrote an article about the advantages (and some potential pitfalls) of scenario planning.  At Nonprofits Assistance Fund, we love scenario planning for the reasons laid out in McKinsey Quarterly:

Scenarios are a powerful tool in the strategist’s armory. They are particularly useful in developing strategies to navigate the kinds of extreme events we have recently seen in the world economy. Scenarios enable the strategist to steer a course between the false certainty of a single forecast and the confused paralysis that often strike in troubled times.

What’s in your Planning Toolbox?

Here are some resources that can help you craft your own scenarios.

You can also read Kate’s post on this topic, What H1N1 Taught Me About Contingency Planning.

October 7, 2009

Finding Inspiration in Unlikely Places

Filed under: Minnesota, Miscellaneous — ashley @ 2:34 pm

You may have heard that there was quite a ball game last night (coverage here, here, and everywhere).

The state of Minnesota (including yours truly) is celebrating a playoff berth for a plucky squad of baseball players, assumed out of the running after All-Star slugger and 2006 AL MVP Justin Morneau’s season ended on September 16th.  But contributions came from unexpected places and the Twins went 17-4, winning their last 5 games including last night’s tie-breaker.

Yesterday, looking forward to the game, I started thinking about what nonprofits could take away from this transformation. 

Put On Your Rally Cap

At Nonprofits Assistance Fund, we have been encouraging organziations to consider new ways to generate revenue and/or trim expenses to build a sustainable business model in this economy.

Morneau was a major run producer (or income source).  And even with him in the lineup, the Twins were barely hanging on.  How could the team adjust their strategy (business model) in order to be successful? 

On twitter and facebook, I asked what nonprofits could learn from this turnaround, and here are some responses:

  • What about an angle on hanging in there like the Twins tied to [nonprofits] in tough times and tackling new approaches.
  • That even superstars need to be surrounded by great teams for success.
  • Bench strength rules. Always play hard.
  • We shouldn’t be overly dependent on one [income] source.
  • Lean…They run that org lean. Plus, they’re great with crisis management aka injury replacement moves.

Here are some additional takeaways:

  • Use your lineup: The Twins are carrying three catchers because they think that gives them the best chance to win. What do your staff, board, and volunteers bring to the table? Take advantage of your in house skills.
  • Be flexible: I think I’ve seen Nick Punto play every position.  Jason Kubel, the designated hitter,  is now playing full time in the outfield. Are there ways to be flexible with program delivery, fundraising, or communications? Are there expenses that you could defer?
  • Play smart defense and don’t commit errors: Make sure that you have the systems in place in order to be successful. Good management systems can prevent and minimize some challenges.
  • Swing for the fences: Other players stepped up to produce runs in Morneau’s absence.  Make your case to donors, foundations, and the community.
  • Be a good sport: Take a note from Brandon Inge and Jim Leyland when things don’t go your way.  If another organization receives a sought after grant or contract, be gracious. Focus on the good work that will be done in the community, rather than your disappointment.
  • Don’t give up.

One last thought, from Harvard Business’s Tip of the Day – 3 Survival Lessons from Small Business:

Planning. Plans are often outdated as soon as they come out of the printer. Small businesses tend to focus more on planning and less on plans. They watch their surroundings and act accordingly.

Let’s play ball.

This blog is cross posted at Balancing the Mission Checkbook.

August 20, 2009

Transparency is a Two Way Street

Filed under: Economy, Financial Management Resources, Foundations, HR, Minnesota, Social Enterprise — Tags: , , , , — ashley @ 1:06 pm

Transparency as a Planning Tool

National Council of Nonprofits has produced a series of Special Reports on the economy.  Their most recent update, Strategies Being Used by Nonprofit Leaders To Cope with the Nation’s Economic Crisis, summarizes findings from a range of reports and provides some key takeaways.  I found the first tip is particularly interesting:

[B]eing transparent about financial challenges and “staying close to funders” emerged as an essential strategy for many organizations. Savvy nonprofits are asking grantmakers to be transparent – because nonprofits need to know how much to expect, and within what timeframe, in order to conduct realistic financial planning. For instance, asking foundations to expedite payments,  in these times when “cash flow” for many nonprofits feels like “cash drip,” is a fair thing to ask.  Likewise, it is better to hear bad news – that a grant will be smaller, or delayed, or even discontinued – earlier rather than later so that adjustments can be made immediately.

Until you have information about the likelihood and timing of grants and other sources of revenue, it’s hard to engage in realistic contingency planning.  The Minnesota Council of Foundations is doing their best to gather and aggregate data on how Minnesota grantmakers are responding to economy.

Nonprofits Assistance Fund has also created materials to help organizations manage cash flow and make informed financial management decisions.

To see all of our financial management tools and articles, visit the Resources section of our website.

Nonprofit Harvest

Training and Resources

Social Enterprise

News and Other Updates

July 8, 2009

A Capital Idea

Filed under: Economy, Minnesota, Social Enterprise — Tags: , , , , , — ashley @ 4:37 pm

Cash Reserves and Access to Capital

As some organizations are tapping into their cash reserves to minimize the impact of diminishing resources on their programs, the question of how to use and manage these funds keeps surfacing.

On one hand, organizations lucky enough to have this rainy day fund are wise to consider best practices and consult their own internal policies around using reserves.  The Foundation Center recently did a feature, How Much Should My Nonprofit Have in Operating Reserves? Review their article for a list of resources.

However, the time may have come to ask a different set of questions. In Beyond Cash Reserves, Kate advocates for a new kind of thinking about cash – that working capital is king:

Rather than dwelling on the best practice or target for designated cash reserve accounts, maybe nonprofits need to learn to be more sophisticated managers of cash and its relative, working capital.

The Social Innovation Fund

Tactical Philanthropy is covering the Social Innovation Fund (What Exactly is the Social Innovation Fund? and Why the Social Innovation Fund Matters).  He draws attention to a number of reasons this is an important development, but he keys in on the value of growth capital:

The Social Innovation Fund is the first meaningful incentive for large foundations to provide growth capital to nonprofits.

The Fund is providing cash grants to grantmakers. Most grantmakers are stuck with the endowment they have and do not have access to additional funding. But the Fund requires that grantmakers use this money (plus matching funds from the foundation’s endowment) to provide growth capital and capacity building grants to nonprofits.

L3C – The New Kid on the Block

Increased access to capital is one reason the L3C model is such a hot topic (we have covered it here before).   A new post from Foundation Center does a good job of summarizing the available information and discussion about L3C, including sharing some examples from Vermont. To learn more you can also read Notes from Capital Sources, Options, and Structures.

Another Round of Reports

The Minnesota Perspective

The Minnesota Council on Foundations (MCF) has released an updated 2009 Outlook report.  Key findings include:

  • In March 2009, 52% of Minnesota grantmakers said they expect to decrease grantmaking in 2009, more than the 40% who anticipated decreases in November 2008.

  • Nearly half of Minnesota grantmakers expect giving will remain the same (31%) or increase (17%) in 2009 compared to 2008. In November, 41% expected grantmaking to remain the same in 2009, while 15% expected increases.

  • In relation to the economic downturn, grantmakers say they are most likely to provide support for food, housing and jobs.

  • Minnesota grantmakers report the most likely ways they will cut operating costs is by reducing travel and conference attendance, eliminating salary increases, and reducing or eliminating the use of consultants.

Warren Woolfe at the Star Tribune recently covered the struggles of Minnesota’s nonprofits to address rising needs with fewer resources in his article, Anxiety on the rise at area’s nonprofits.  You can also read MinnPost’s three-part story on the Minnesota economy, starting with The big question for economic recovery: Which stresses are merely cyclical and which indicate a cold, new reality?

The National Perspective

The Chronicle of Philanthropy also reported on two national surveys on the impact of the recession on the nonprofit sector:

  • Ninety-two percent of the nearly 100 respondents in a survey conducted in May by the Bridgespan Group said they were feeling the effects of the downturn.
  • Eighty percent of charity officials reported that their organizations were experiencing financial stress, in another study conducted in April by the Johns Hopkins University’s Listening Post Project. Nearly 40 percent of the 363 respondents described the stress as “severe.”

Two findings from the Bridgespan Survey struck me as particularly timely:

Finding No. 2: More organizations are tapping into reserves. Also, more nonprofit leaders are developing contingency plans, a key step that can help them respond purposefully when crises arise, and also prepare for better times ahead.

Finding No. 3: The deepening recession has led more nonprofits to lay off staff and reduce program activity, while taking action to protect core services and activities. The specific tactics used to cope with the downturn have varied by organization size. But now, more than ever, it is important to identify the people who matter most to an organization, and to keep that group strong.

If you need help grappling with these decisions, you can visit our resource page. It has contingency planning tools and other resources from Nonprofits Assistance Fund and other capacity building organizations.

Nonprofit Harvest

Summer Bloggin’

This summer we’re going to be writing this blog every few weeks. We’re working on some exciting projects, so stay tuned for information about new opportunities.

If you need a regular dose of nonprofit financial management news, follow us on twitter. You can also check out Tactical Philanthropy’s Daily Digest, PhilanTopic’s Weekend Link Roundup,  or Not-For Profit Accounting’s Nonprofit News feature.

June 19, 2009

Survey Says…

Filed under: Data, Economy, Financial Management Resources, Minnesota — Tags: , , , , — ashley @ 3:18 pm

Minnesota’s Current Conditions

On the heels of last week’s post on the Giving USA annual study, we have more data to digest. MCN recently released their Current Conditions Report for June 2009:

Minnesota’s nonprofits continue to be seriously affected by the recession. Nonprofits are bracing for extended impacts from the reduction in revenue they have already seen and expect to continue to see in the coming months and years.

  • Organizations relying on state, local or federal government are seeing varying levels of unreliability in payments to them from government, making it increasingly difficult for organizations to plan accordingly. Exacerbating this is the threat of unallotment for many organizations.
  • A majority of organizations report an increase in demand for services, yet many are still having to cut back on staff.
  • All major nonprofit revenue sources (contributions, government funding, foundation grants, and earned income) are reported to be down from economic affects.
  • Small organizations are feeling the worst affects, with far more reporting declines in revenue and cash shortfalls. Small organizations are also the least likely to have available reserves or a line of credit to fall back on.

These findings are echoed by other studies (here and here).  Although the specifics vary from state to state, and among organization type and size, people in our sector are doing their best to meet demands with fewer resources.

We are all trying to prudently cut costs in ways that minimize the impact on our mission and overall capacity. This is a tall order, especially when combined with increasing needs for service. How do you go about making those tough choices?

A Four Step Framework

Our executive director, Kate Barr and Judy Alnes of MAP for Nonprofits wrote an article for MCF’s Winter Giving Forum, Nonprofit Survival: Four Steps to Take Now:

Economic uncertainty and the threat of impending doom are not unfamiliar territory for nonprofit organizations. We’ve lived through multiple downturns and have “right-sized” ourselves time and time again. Philanthropic organizations have done likewise.

But something feels uncharted about this downturn. Perhaps it’s the fact that it has fallen on the heels of a downturn from which we never really recovered. Perhaps the global nature of the economic stress makes us see ourselves in a broader context. In any event, this fire is real and hot.

Then they lay out four steps to help you make decisions:

  • Focus
  • Identify Your Most Important Work
  • Seek and Speak Financial Truth
  • Review Size, Scope and Structure

Read the rest of the article for more information on this helpful framework.

Other Resources

More resources are available at Sustenance in Lean Times, our resource collection.

This Week’s Harvest

April 17, 2009

How’s Your Cash Flow?

Filed under: Financial Management Resources, Minnesota, News, Social Enterprise — Tags: , , , , , , , — ashley @ 2:16 pm

Are You Concerned About Cash?

Blue Avocado’s new issue includes the financial management article, Finance Fear Factor Ratios.  Unfortunately, a number of people can probably relate to this experience:

A CFO at a troubled organization told me, “The first and last thing I do in the morning and evening is look at our bank balance and see if we have enough cash to meet our next payroll. The budget looks fine, but cash flow is our biggest problem.”

How do you know whether or not you should worry?  Read the rest of the article for ratios and four key questions to help you recognize red flags.

You can also read Cash is Cash, Sometimes for information on what could impact your ability to access your organization’s cash.  And our handy Cash Flow Template is available to help you craft your own cash flow projections.

Calling All Minnesota Social Entrepreneurs

Don’t miss your opportunity to enter the Social Entrepreneurs Cup – a joint venture of Social Venture Partners Minnesota and the Minnesota Cup.  This competition “seeks out, supports, and celebrates Minnesota’s most innovative and effective social entrepreneurs and the nonprofit organizations they lead.”

The deadline is Friday, April 24th, so you have one more week to enter.  It’s an opportunity to win a $20,000 general operating grant and 40 hours of consulting from Social Ventures Partners.

In the News: This Week’s Harvest

  • USA Today launched a new feature specifically for the nonprofit and philanthropic community.  Check out the Sharing section for news on our sector.
Older Posts »